Welcome to Jake's Pizza Company

126 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204, United States

General Info

If you’re cruising down Sunset Blvd in West Cape May, Jake’s Pizza Company is the kind of place that instantly catches your attention-not just for the bright, welcoming signage, but for the unmistakable aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. Stepping inside, the casual vibe immediately makes you feel at ease, whether you’re here for a solo dinner or a group outing. The space is thoughtfully designed with a wheelchair accessible entrance and plenty of onsite seating, so accessibility and comfort are clearly a priority alongside the food.

The menu at Jake’s Pizza Company is a delight for anyone who appreciates classic pizza done right, but with a twist of bold flavors. Their Bacon Pizza is a standout, delivering crispy, smoky bites that pair perfectly with the gooey, melted cheese. If you’re in the mood for something a little heartier, the Sausage and Onion Pizza hits all the right notes with savory sausage and just the right amount of sweetness from caramelized onions. And it’s not all pizza-fans of finger foods can’t miss the Buffalo Wings, perfectly seasoned and spicy enough to give you a satisfying kick without overpowering your palate. For something a bit different, the Jerk Chicken Cheese Steak is a must-try, blending tender, spiced chicken with melty cheese in a way that keeps people coming back for more.

One thing that really sets this spot apart is the commitment to fresh ingredients. Every slice feels vibrant and carefully crafted, showing that quality is a priority on every plate. Whether you’re enjoying a quiet meal alone or catching up with friends, there’s something comforting about the way Jake’s balances indulgence with freshness. Parking is easy and convenient, so you won’t have to worry about finding a spot after a long day, and the friendly staff ensures that each visit feels personal and welcoming.

Even beyond the food, the experience at Jake’s Pizza Company is memorable. The casual, relaxed atmosphere encourages diners to linger over a meal without feeling rushed. The combination of flavorful pizza options, dependable service, and thoughtful accommodations makes it clear why this location has garnered positive chatter in local reviews. For anyone in West Cape May looking for a pizza spot that delivers both in taste and experience, Jake’s hits the mark every time.

The variety and flavor, paired with the attentive service, make every visit feel fresh, casual, and downright enjoyable, ensuring that Jake’s Pizza Company remains a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike.

Jake's Pizza Company Photos 2

Jake's Pizza Company Photos

Icon

What customers say?

“ Amazing pizzeria — very professional and absolutely delicious. A real, authentic pizzeria! We’re just passing through on vacation, and what an incredible discovery! Thank you, and don’t hesitate for a single second! ”

- DT TE -

“ Jake’s pizza is the best kept secret in Cape May!!! We went here a few years ago on the way to sunset beach. And this trip - we went twice!! I had their chicken parm sandwich- amazing- they packaged it so great for our to go order. My husband tried the Stromboli- I had the left overs the next day- amazing!!! Their fries are the best we had all week!! My son only eats tenders and fries. So he’s knows when they’re good!! Our pizza last night was delicious!!! Thank you for having us!! We’ll be back next year for sure! ”

- Sarah Jane -

“ Stopped by for a quick visit after visiting Cape May light house. Pizza was excellent with very nice crust made fresh as we waited. Definitely a sport for local workers at lunch time always a sign of good quality food and service. Definitely worth the money. Nice picnic tables outside to enjoy your lunch. ”

- joe celona -

“ My friends and I started off our evening attempting to homemake pizza. We are in air bnb and didn’t have flour. So we made the decision anyone would and ordered pizza take-out instead. To say that was a life changing decision is an understatement. 15 minutes after calling we picked up our pizza and were greeted by the carrier of this life changing pizza. The aroma of this pizza filled the car and it was delightful. Our excitement grew as we opened up the box. We sat down and devoured the pizza that may be the best pizza I have ever had. We are from an area with a lot of good pizza, but nothing compares to these slices of heaven. If I could give this place 20/5 stars I genuinely would. I wholeheartedly recommend anyone in the one hour radius of this heaven on earth “Jake’s Pizza” to try it. You won’t regret it. Thanks for the amazing service and even better pizza. ”

- Meghan Minghini -

“ Great food and fast service. I've had their pizza, cheese steaks, and chicken parm subs. Always tasty. Definitely recommend eating here ”

- Fed up with Sht service -

“ From northern Nj and have high expectations when it comes to a good pizza. Jake’s met the mark, this was a very tasty pizza, compared well to any good pie we have gotten up north. Would reccomend as a go to local pizza spot. ”

- Drew -

“ Best pizza/calzone/ Stromboli in Cape May county . Have recommended Jakes many times and never disappoints ! Even though he frowns apron lettuce tomato and onion in his Stromboli’s he did it anyway and was absolutely relishes ! ”

- Danette DiDonato -

“ Hands down best pizza on the island, Jake single handedly puts all other pizza places to shame. Great cheese to crust ratio with the perfect amount of crunch Highly recommend! ”

- Daniel Camp -
Jake's Pizza Company Photos 9

Location & Contact

call to book a table & delivery:
information Jake's Pizza Company:

126 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204, United States

See more food places

Cafe
823 Dobong-ro, Dobong-gu, Seoul, South Korea
Restaurant
Calle 6 entre 10 y 15 av, Centro, 77710 Playa del Carmen, Q.R., Mexico
Restaurant
Gåxsjö 300, 833 49 Hammerdal, Sweden
Restaurant
Hansaallee 321, 40549 Düsseldorf, Germany
Coffee Shop
72922 Baker Blvd, Baker, CA 92309, United States